Ive learned enough with them to know anything resembling raid 5 is a horrible idea. Given two hard disks the minimum, a block of data to be written is split into two equal parts andwritten on the two disks. Now when the system is up and running you must configure the raid 5 and format a volume. I am coming from openfiler, which i was using for a long time. I recommend at least a raid 5 configuration, either hardware or software, on storage systems, so a minimum of three hard disks would be necessary. For more information, please see the wikipedia article on raid raid 0 blocklevel striping without parity. The main power of raid 5 is derived from the fact that here, parity information is distributed among the drives such that even if one and only one of the drives fails but the others are working, everything will continue to. The reason for this is that every write to a particular disk needs to update the parity block, so therefore every write. In our testing environment, we are about to use with 4 numbers of 1 tb disks. Using the intergrated 1 gbe link i was able to saturate the gbe connection giving about 114mb readsec.
Openfiler provides key features such as iscsi target for virtualization, fibre channel target support, block level replication and high availabilty. Software raid openfiler software raid allows the administrator to aggregate physical and virtual block devices to increase usable capacity, enhance block io performance and provide extended reliability and availability. As a unified storage solution, openfiler aims to combine the best features of nas storage with the best features on san storage. Hardware raid controller the website further mentions that openfiler is compatible with 32bit and 64bit industry standard server hardware too.
With openfiler, you can go with software raid, which requires processor muscle, especially with potentially twenty. Openfiler nas unified storage overview and installation. Re3 drives on a raid6 using openfiler liinux software raid, tyan server board running core2duo 2. I dont know exact numbers for iscsi and nfs, freenas is often blamed for its poor sambacifs performance. In this thread i take a look at the performance capababilities of three free iscsi target software platforms.
Ive started testing the drives with a ultimate boot cd hdd32 4. First we are going to configure our raid5 array, and then install openfiler on our system disk. Before proceeding for installation, kindly have below requirement for hardware and virtualization specification needed to deploy this. San is a dedicated highperformance network for consolidated block level storage. Im currently swaying towards openfiler because write speeds over cifs are better than freenas 85mbs vs 55mbs, but performance isnt such a game changer but would be nice. It is a fullfledged nassan that can be implemented as a virtual appliance for vmware and xen hypervisors. Now i have to configure that server for the freenas, but i have found that the freenas wont support the hardware raid. I did a lot of test with nas4free, zfs on 4 hdd, software raid 5 from the menu. Raid 5 data recovery recover data from damaged raid 5 array. In some cases, raid 10 offers faster data reads and writes than raid 5 because it does not need to manage parity.
Storage management using openfiler, part 2 linux for you. The additional levels raidz2 and raidz3 offer double and triple parity protection, respectively. Creating software raid and volumes on openfiler storage. Key features include the zfs file system, software raid levels 0, 1 or 5 and disk encryption. Multiple software raid arrays are supported, and any block device physical or virtual can participate as a raid member. Raid level 5 performance is scalable, as more disks provide more independent access. Openfiler is a storage management operating system based on rpath linux. A standard sata ii hard disk gives a write speed of 6 gigabits per second. Nas upload speed tests 1x hdd vs 3 hdd raid 5 vs ssd raid 0. Everything ive read says that you should be looking to use either 3 or 5 drives in your raid 5 software arrays. Raid 10 would be ideal for safety, but as this is almost purely a write system, not a read system, it isnt going to buy you performance. In our previous article we have a walkthrough openfiler installation guide, now let us focus on creating a software raid, volumes, block devices and sharing them across a network range.
Take away one disk for parity and you are left with 3 disks to stripe across in a 4. Software raid is usually used in conjunction with a storage array to. The os has minimal load so what you could do and i do is pick up a pair of cheap old small laptop drives and mirror them and use them for the os. Btw, for software raid solution, which software has better performance, openfiler, freenas or something else. For raid 5 you need three minimum hard drive disks. Freenas suggests a parity arrangement based on the number of available disks, and allows you to override that suggestion with a custom one. They will be added as a member into anyone of raid level. Openfiler storage appliances fully compatible servers. Openfiler supports raid levels 0, 1, 5, 6 and 10, which are explained in brief for ready reference.
Raidz, the software raid that is part of zfs, offers single parity protection like raid 5, but without the write hole vulnerability thanks to the copyonwrite architecture of zfs. I recently did some performance tests for a couple virtualization technologies. Installed freenas now, performance not really satisfied. This is present in the beta and final release of the software and was getting frustrating, however there is a fix. Up until windows 8, software raid in windows was a mess. The additional levels raidz2 and raidz3 offer double and triple parity protection respectively.
Read speeds were about the same between freenas and the raid card, until the 2gb cache ran out on the card then it would drop. The best open source software for network attached storage. After getting the dell r730, i was able to get better performance using the h730p raid card with my sas3 ssd drives then on the freenas server. Software raid vs hardware raid hard disk drives hdd. Freenas vs openfiler dilemma overclockers uk forums. Turn your machine into enterprise storage with openfiler.
It supports software and hardware raid, monitoring and. Openfiler storage creating software raid and volumes. Linux software raid is damn good and it beats low end raid controllers and usually matches performance of midend ones. Openfiler is a centos and rpathbased network operating system, and its compatible with 64bit industry standard server hardware. It offers storage administrators a set of powerful tools that are used to manage complex storage environments. First of all, you wont see very high mbs on a software raid5 set consisting of only three drives. Lost raid5 on openfiler solutions experts exchange. Openfiler is an opensource nas you, this video demonstrates creating software raid using openfiler for more information please visit. Ive tried both freenas raidz1 and openfiler software raid 5 and i really like them both for different reasons and i cant decided which one to go for.
Read performance will be ok, but write performance wont be so hot. Raid 5 software not zfs in 2 years, one hdd have a physical failed. Raid 5 blocklevel striping with distributed parity. I will be comparing file copy performance as well as raw inputoutput operations. Availability openfiler supports activepassive high availability clustering, mpio, and block level replication. Ti means that only through the console youll use your root password which you did setup during the installation steps. Ubuntu, openfiler or freenas i might consider software raid 10 to get more readwrite performance im new to linux, considering ubuntu server, but really no clue how to install and configure it. One of the other posters indicated you should run a dd test against the raid md device to determine local performance.
A software mirror raid 10 equivalent option is also available for maximum performance. Openfiler is a linux based open source operating system that provides. Why is a single drive much faster than 4 of them in raid5. Freenas openfiler microsoft iscsi performance shootout. Navigate to volumes software raid to create the new raid array.
Raid 5 vs raid 10 for home nas techexams community. I dont need any gui additions, so i prefer a plain linux distro and use ssh for management. We gathered the latest generation of raid controllers at our test lab to show off their performance and features. I ran the benchmarks using various chunk sizes to see if that had an effect on either hardware or software configurations for the. It can also be installed in a virtualmachine environment such as vmware or xenserver, as a guest os. This is a chance for you to at least correct some of that with a business class os and raid 10. Reliability openfiler supports both software and hardware raid with monitoring and alert facilities. Raid is a necessary building block when undertaking a data protection initiative. In testing both software and hardware raid performance i employed six 750gb samsung sata drives in three raid configurations 5, 6, and 10. One of them will be used for the os and cant be used for other raid configuration. Step by step installation guide for using openfiler as. As for the raid itself, its a software raid, not an hardware one. Openfiler ensures that storage administrators are able to make the best use of system performance and storage capacity resources when allocating and managing storage in a multiplatform network. Raid redundant array of inexpensive disks raid wasnt originally about performance, it was about cost.
Instead, it has the software raid but the software raid requires 5 hdds. Raid 6 is about as close of a resemblance as you can get without actually being raid 5. It includes zfs v5000, software raid 0,1,5, disk encryption. Openfiler raid configuration software raid5 youtube. The mobo im getting does mobo raid and since this is only going to be for a home nas there should be enough cycles left on the cpu to handle it. Software raid 5 against zfs performance post by mauro23. Features freenas open source storage operating system. Raid 5 is not meant for reliability, whoever designed this made some pretty wild risky choices openfiler, raid 5, below entry level server hardware, etc. Windows 7 has arbitrary restrictions on the available raid levels, and it was impossible to create a level 5 raid without windows server. Put xfs or even well set ext3, lvm2 on top of it, and you have very flexible solution open for expansion in the future.
How to test raid 5 in openfiler by remove hard disk and add hard disk. Software raid under linux is pretty stellar feature, and its cpu cost, especially with current hardware, is neglible. Setting up file server ubuntu, openfiler and freenas. Storage management using openfiler, part 1 linux for you.
Contains comprehensive benchmarking of linux ubuntu 7. It can also be installed in a virtual machine environment as a guest os in citrix xenserver, and vmware vsphere. Openfiler raid card suggestion solutions experts exchange. The disk io performance loss in xen vms xenserver 5.
I have a server with 16 gb ram and 4x1tb hdds configured as raid 10. Given two hard disks the minimum, a block of data to be written is split into two equal parts and written on the two disks. Openfiler supports raid 0, raid 1, raid 5, raid 6 and raid 10. Fast, gigabit and 10 gigabit ethernet controllers from intel and broadcom can also be integrated to provide high bandwidth access to data over a tcpip network. Openfiler supports a plethora of hardware raid and fibre channel controllers and disk technologies such as sas, sata and scsi. Iomega ix4 v openfiler performance testing everything.
450 1415 808 564 556 1652 807 114 1107 410 1574 625 1054 1239 385 324 1063 395 697 709 1591 1642 1058 1229 1249 244 482 532 1176 799 821 49 720 1052 1105